Boards of Fame · Founders Board 16 Nov 2026

La Bourdonnais: The World's Best Before Chess Had a World Champion

Source: FIDE Historical Committee / Edward Winter

Long before the first official world championship, Louis-Charles Mahé de La Bourdonnais dominated European chess. His rivalry with Alexander McDonnell in 1834 helped turn great games into a record that later players could actually study.

Chess had leading players long before it had a world champion.

In the first half of the nineteenth century, there was no official title to defend, no international rating list and no governing body deciding who should challenge whom. Reputations were made at the board, usually in cafés and private clubs, and settled through matches.

Louis-Charles Mahé de La Bourdonnais had perhaps the strongest claim to being the leading player of his generation. Yet what makes him important is not just that he won. It is that so much of his chess survives.

From the Café de la Régence to the top of European chess

La Bourdonnais made his name at the Café de la Régence in Paris, one of Europe's leading chess meeting places.

He learnt the game in 1814 and was playing seriously by 1818. His teachers included Jacques François Mouret and Alexandre Deschapelles, who had inherited France's leading chess reputation after Philidor's era.

By 1821, La Bourdonnais had overtaken Deschapelles in direct competition. He strengthened that standing by travelling to London, beating William Lewis in 1823 and meeting more of Britain's strongest players.

Calling him a world champion would be wrong. The official title did not exist until 1886. Calling him one of the strongest players of the period, and probably its leading figure, is much better supported.

Chess was no longer just a pastime

La Bourdonnais came from a family that had once been wealthy. Around 1831 he lost much of his fortune in property speculation, although accounts differ on the details.

That changed his relationship with chess. Playing, teaching and writing were ways of earning a living, not simply showing what he could do across a café table. In 1833 he published Nouveau Traité du jeu des échecs, a substantial chess treatise.

There was a practical side to his strength. He needed people willing to play him, patrons willing to support him and readers willing to buy his work. His career belongs to the early history of professional chess as much as it belongs to the history of great players.

London, 1834: a rivalry worth recording

The defining contest came in London in 1834. La Bourdonnais faced Alexander McDonnell, an Irish master based in Britain, at the Westminster Chess Club.

From June to October the pair played a long series traditionally recorded as six matches and 85 games. La Bourdonnais came out ahead overall. The commonly published result gives him 45 wins, McDonnell 27 and 13 draws.

There is a qualification worth making. Historical accounts disagree about the exact totals, especially the unfinished sixth match. Nick Pope's work on the original reports shows why those familiar figures should be treated as the conventional record, not an unquestionable count.

The conditions were very different from modern tournament chess. There were no chess clocks. McDonnell could spend well over an hour considering a move, while La Bourdonnais often replied quickly. Games lasted for hours and sometimes continued the following day.

A match lasting months, between two players with markedly different temperaments, provided a great deal of material. Fortunately, someone was keeping score.

The man who wrote the moves down

William Greenwood Walker, a member of the Westminster Chess Club and a supporter of McDonnell, recorded the games. His work gave later generations something previous eras had often lacked: a substantial sequence of top level encounters that could be replayed, compared and analysed.

The scores were subsequently published, and chess writers including Howard Staunton returned to them. Edward Winter's historical collection traces the contemporary accounts and the later corrections.

This mattered beyond the result. Openings could be examined against actual competitive evidence rather than passed on largely through assertion and anecdote.

The 1834 series includes early important examples of the Sicilian Defence, the Evans Gambit and the Queen's Gambit. The famous sixty second game, won by La Bourdonnais with Black, ends with an extraordinary advance of connected passed pawns.

That position deserves its own article. For now, it is a reminder that the games were not simply historical curiosities. They were material from which other players could learn.

Brilliant chess, but not flawless chess

It is easy to watch one of these attacking games and conclude that the players must have been impossibly strong. It is just as easy to run modern analysis over the moves and dismiss them for errors that today's best players would avoid.

Neither judgement tells the whole story.

La Bourdonnais had an impressive understanding of activity, initiative and the power of advancing pawns. The games also contain tactical mistakes and uneven technique. They were played in a different competitive environment, without the opening resources or analytical tools we now take for granted.

What stands out is the ambition. Both players kept seeking complicated positions and chances to win. Their matches are valuable because we can see their ideas, their mistakes and their responses over a large body of games, rather than relying on a handful of famous moves.

A new kind of chess publication

The recorded matches were not his only contribution to the way chess was studied.

In 1836, La Bourdonnais and the writer Joseph Méry founded Le Palamède, widely described as the first magazine devoted to chess. The idea of regular chess journalism, bringing games and analysis to readers beyond the club where they were played, was taking shape.

La Bourdonnais was helping to make chess a subject people could follow, discuss and revisit. In that respect, he connects Philidor's influential chess book with the larger world of chess writing that developed later in the nineteenth century.

A legacy that outlasted his short life

His final years were difficult. After illness and financial hardship, La Bourdonnais died in London on 13 December 1840. He was buried at Kensal Green Cemetery, where McDonnell had been buried five years earlier. Howard Staunton would also be buried there.

Even the basic details of his early life require care. Older biographies commonly give a birth year of 1795 and place him on Réunion or in Brittany. More recent archival research favours 25 May 1797 in Paris, but that identification has not erased every historical disagreement. The documentation assembled by Edward Winter is a useful starting point.

His claim to greatness does not need an invented world title or a perfectly tidy biography.

La Bourdonnais helped establish what top level chess could look like when matches were recorded and studied. The contest with McDonnell gave later generations a body of games. His writing helped make chess a continuing public conversation.

That is a substantial legacy for a player who never had an official world championship to win.

Explore the Founders Board and our feature on Philidor's contribution to chess strategy.

Further reading and sources

This article is based on the IMSC La Bourdonnais research dossier, especially its biography, 1834 matches, playing style, historical record and legacy sections. Independent checks include the FIDE Historical Committee's account of the period, Edward Winter's historical research, ChessBase's review of the McDonnell rivalry and Nick Pope's investigation of the sixth match.

Season 1

Follow the build and join the club

Join Inter Mezzo Sporting Club for free and follow the launch of Lega Inter Mezzo, the Training Centre and the Season One shop preview.

Join